The Best Eyebrow Pencils Made with Organic Ingredients
When it comes to a great makeup look, the eyebrows can really pull it all together. With so many different variations of eyebrow products and different brands it can be hard to determine which one(s) we should choose.
This guide will address what an eyebrow pencil is, some harmful ingredients to look out for, and some brands using organic ingredients.
This post does contain some affiliate links. If you decide to make a purchase The Honest Consumer will receive a commission. Our commission is at no additional cost to you.
What Is An Eyebrow Pencil?
If you’ve never included doing your eyebrows in your look you may be wondering how it works, or why you should add this product to your makeup routine.
Eyebrow pencils are similar to eyeliners in some ways. The goal of using this product is to apply a tint of color to your brow, the color is going to be your natural hair color.
By doing this you are filling, shaping, and defining your brow. All you do is fill in your brows with the pencil using light strokes being sure to get the individual hairs. Then using a brush and brow gel you want to shape your brows and make sure they lay right.
If you have brow gel you have options between clear brow gel for a natural finish or tinted gel for a more dramatic look. That is for another post though.
Why should I use an eyebrow pencil?
Even if you are lucky enough to have been born with full brows, you still may want to add some definition to your brows to tame any unruly hairs. For everyone else, you want to use a brow pencil to essentially make your brows look fuller than they are.
Just make sure that you are choosing the right shade that looks natural and not making them look overly full. This will help you achieve a natural look that makes it look like you have no makeup on, if that is the look you are going for.
Here is a great tutorial to use.
Eyebrow pencils can be a great tool for anyone with sparse brows, anyone who loves make up, or professional makeup artists.
What tools do I use?
Depending on whether or not your eyebrow pencil comes with a brush, I’d recommend an eyebrow brush to help smooth unruly brows.
Then to finish your look I’d recommend also purchasing an eyebrow gel to lock your brows in place.
If I just confused you by throwing another product at you, check out this article that breaks down the differences between those two, and a few other brow products.
Why Organic Eyebrow Pencils Are The Better Choice
Beauty products are an important category to think about when it comes to organic products, especially if you have sensitive skin.
While the beauty industry hasn’t fully caught up to how important it is to have clean, non-toxic products, there are companies out there working to better the beauty industry.
Make up companies using organic ingredients and sustainable practices are brands you want to be buying your beauty products, including eyebrow pencils, from.
You may be wondering why you should go that extra mile to seek out a natural eyebrow pencil. There are three main reasons: your skin, for the people creating the products, and the environment.
Your skin: Putting a product that has the wrong ingredient in it can not only cause something small like an allergic reaction, you could also get a serious illness and even cancer. That’s why it’s best to go with products made with all natural ingredients.
The people manufacturing the product: When you are dealing with toxins there are always risks involved. The more in-demand the products filled with these dangerous chemicals become, the more that gets made, which can be hazardous.
The environment: Not only is the product getting washed down the drain or thrown in a landfill when you end the night and take your makeup off, the packaging is also most likely in the landfill as well. When it comes to brands that prioritize natural ingredients and products, they usually also find sustainability important too. This means their packaging is most likely recyclable.
You see now why going for the more organic option is best, so let’s talk ingredients.
Ingredients to Love & Ingredients to Avoid
In this section we are going to get clear on what to look for on the ingredient label of each eyebrow product you are interested in.
Research is your best friend when it comes to clean beauty, so hopefully by knowing what to look for and what to avoid, shopping will be easier for you.
Ingredients To Avoid
Let’s get the bad out of the way first. There are some ingredients, like parabens, that you can find in many beauty products. Here are some that are more unique to brow products.
Carbon black: Our first toxic ingredient is linked to potential cancer and organ system toxicity.
Benzalkonium chloride (BAK): While this is typically used as a preservative it can be potentially toxic to cells in your eyes.
Heavy metals: Lung cancer and respiratory concerns are potential concerns from these types of toxic ingredients.
Aluminum powder: This has been known to be a neurotoxin and has also been linked to organ system toxicity.
Ingredients You’ll Love
While the ingredients above might not be so great, check out what these cleaner ingredients can do for you when you choose an organic eyebrow pencil instead of a traditional one.
These are ingredients you'll want to look for next time you find yourself in the makeup aisle!
Organic Coconut Oil: coconut oil has many great benefits that your skin will love.Two of those are reducing dull skin and the appearance of fine lines.
Shea Butter: shea butter is great for moisturizing your skin and handy to have if it’s feeling dry.
Vitamin E: This is another ingredient that provides great nourishment. It also prevents UV damage.
Castor Seed Oil: This great ingredient helps promote better skin health and can soothe skin inflammation.
3 Organic Eyebrow Pencils to Try
If you're looking for some of the best eyebrow pencils that are made with organic ingredients, this list is for you!
Inika Organics Professional Quality Made with Organic Ingredients
The Inika Organic Brow Pencil provides a matte finish in three different colors. It’s also a great option for all skin types.
This creamy pencil is made of an all-natural formula featuring all-star ingredients Vitamin E and Certified Organic Coconut Oil. You can purchase it for $23.
Inika Organics was founded in 2006 in Sydney Australia. They have won many awards for their innovation and dedication to the clean beauty world. While they are 100% Australian-owned, their products can be found in 35 countries.
Inika Organics go beyond staying pure when it comes to what’s in the products, they are also concerned with the packaging of their products. In fact, 90% of their packaging is made from sustainable & reusable materials.
This company is all about clean beauty every step of the way.
Au Naturale's Soft Tip Pencil
Next up on the list of the best organic eyebrow pencils is the Brow Boss Organic Brow Pencil from Au Naturale. It’s a soft-tip pencil that glides over your brows, making for an easy application with no tugging or pulling.
This beauty product is vegan, cruelty-free, and hand-crafted.
Their formula contains a range of certified organic and ECOCERT ingredients include Castor oil, MCT from Coconut, and more.
There are five colors that you can choose from. Pro tip- choose a color that most closely matches your eyebrow hair color for more natural results. You can purchase it for $23.
Au Naturale launched in 2011 after founder Ashley Prange created a full line of clean beauty products that left her skin as happy as it did when she wasn’t wearing any products on her face.
Au Naturale is based in Wisconsin but reaches far beyond one state. That has inspired its founder to fight for stricter regulation of cosmetic products in the United States.
Through their Clean Beauty Revolution this company creates products that are in the best interests of the customers, those that create the ingredients, and the Earth.
Sante's Most Affordable Organic Option
Of the eyebrow pencils, this one is the lowest price point.
This Sante’s Eyebrow Pencil is a great option for someone wanting to either switch to natural makeup, or maybe you are just looking for new brow makeup options.
Shea butter is to thank for the creamy formula that delivers a great shape to your eyebrows.
If you are a fan of a fuller look, you’ll love this product. Since it comes with the spoolie brush, you don’t need to buy any brow tools to create the brows you desire.
The organic ingredients in this eyebrow pencil include Jojoba Seed Oil, shea butter, and more. This pencil comes in two different shades and you can purchase it for $21.
Sante is a German company that was founded over 30 years ago. Their desire is to protect the planet and animal welfare while creating products that achieve this as well as ones that are healthy for the customers.
They care for their customers by being committed to using 100% natural ingredients in their beauty products, but they are also careful in choosing those ingredients to make the highest quality product.
This is a company that truly loves what they do and why they do it.
How to Use an Eyebrow Pencil
When it comes to using an eyebrow pencil, the key is to use light, feathery hair-like strokes and blend them into your natural brows. You can start with a lighter color than your desired shade and layer on more as you go.
This will give you the most natural look possible.
Also be sure to brush through your brows after applying the pencil for a seamless and polished look.
And lastly, make sure to sharpen your pencil before each use so that it has the most precise application.
Tips for Switching to a New Eyebrow Pencil
If you're ready to make the switch to a brow pencil made with organic ingredients or start using a eyebrow pencil for the first time, here are a few great tips!
When switching to a new eye makeup, it's always a good idea to start by using small amounts to make sure the ingredients work well with your skin.
Read labels and be aware of the product you're purchasing.
Remember to go with a color that closely matches your natural brow hair.
Set aside a few minutes each morning to take care of your eyebrows.
Don't forget to sharpen your pencil before each use for precise application.
Make sure you blend the product out well for an even and natural look.
Hopefully this guide helped you discover some organic eyebrow pencil options and learn a bit more about what ingredients to look for when shopping for eyebrow pencils.
Meet the Author
Kelly Clark is a freelance writer, who also runs her own blog Budding Joy. When she’s not writing you can find her listening to music, reading, and diving into more sustainable living topics, especially surrounding self care and eco-conscious beauty. Learn more from Kelly on LinkedIn or Instagram.
For more ethical & sustainable tips be sure to follow The Honest Consumer on social media, subscribe to our newsletter, & check out the Ethical & Sustainable Brand Directory.